Sunday 27 January 2013

Nice to meet you, I'm a professional liar.

Nina Bawden
Writers are liars; it's an unavoidable fact. We seek to entertain our readers as much as possible, and while the truth can be stranger than fiction, it isn't always more exciting. Nina Bawden, a childhood favourite author of mine, said that 'All writers are liars. They twist events to suit themselves. They make use of their own tragedies to make a better story... They are terrible people'.

Of course, this is a particularly extreme view when looking at fiction, especially fantasy writing like mine. However, even these pieces can be intended to influence readers with allusions to politics or current affairs. Tolkien's Lord Of The Rings trilogy and even children's books like Tove Jansson's Comet In Moominland are examples of this, both being heavily based on their respective authors' experiences of and views on war.

To look at this from another point of view, though, the views that shape those texts are in a way the truth of the authors' own lives, and this potentially adds something to them. Cheever's short stories, like The Death Of Justina, are revealed in his journals to similarly reflect the truth of his own life and of his inner thoughts. In this review of his journals from The Guardian, Geoff Dyer points out the many themes and images in his stories which are drawn from previous journal entries.

Writers, then, seem to be a strange paradox. We are pathological liars, manipulating reality and the events our lives for entertainment, while at the same time, we cannot help baring our most private truths and our most intimate beliefs to our readers.

3 comments:

  1. But does a lie not depend on the person and the situation. The way i tell my truth my seem a lie to you but it is true to me ?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I heard something interesting about concepts of truth in a radio interview with Sam West (who is playing yet another interpretation of King George VI in the forthcoming Hyde Park on Hudson) and wrote it on the back of an envelope which I cannot currently lay my hands on. To make it up would either be delightfully ironic or terribly unhelpful given the context of the post... :0) I'll, therefore, restrict myself to commenting that the term media derives from a latin word for communication. The earliest attribution of the term has been given to ancient cave paintings. Whether these were attempting to communicate important truths or merely an early form of 'to do' lists is unclear but the idea that they were, as you suggest, some form of manipulation is a credible one...

    ReplyDelete